„CNN“ kelia klausimus dėl „Flydubai“ keleivių skaičiaus sumažėjimo, kurį nurodo Izraelis

2026 m. rugsėjo 30 d. ryte „flydubai“ reisas FZ1073 išskrido iš Dubajaus į Tel Avivą su 174 keleiviais, kurių dauguma buvo izraeliečiai. Maždaug po dviejų valandų lėktuvas ėmė smukti, pasuko į šiaurę ir išsiuntė pagalbos signalą...

Antraštės ir trumpo aprašymo vertimas atliktas automatiškai. Sudomino? Įsijunkite vertimą.


On the morning of 30 September 2026, flydubai flight FZ1073 left Dubai for Tel Aviv with 174 people on board, most of them Israeli. About two hours later the jet dropped, turned north, sent a distress call, and squawked 7500, the code crews use to say a plane is being hijacked. It landed at Tabuk, in Saudi Arabia. Passengers later flew on to Ben Gurion. The captain, an Indian pilot named Smit Machchhar, was badly cut. Israeli leaders called it a foiled mass murder, a near “9/11,” and, a day later, “Hollywood on steroids.”

CNN Pilot Questions Flydubai Drop Numbers Israel Cites

That last line did not come from a critic. It came from Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. People who already did not trust the telling heard a confession. People who did trust it heard a man amazed that a film plot had happened in daylight.

What is no longer in dispute

The airline spoke before the politicians finished their sentences. In its second statement, flydubai said an altercation took place on the flight deck of FZ1073. On-duty flydubai crew who were riding as passengers secured the aircraft, diverted it, and landed it at Tabuk. All passengers and crew were safe. The airline then said the reasons and motives were unknown, and asked everyone to stop guessing while the inquiry ran. Later the same day it suspended flights to and from Israel until that work was done. The words are on the airline’s own update page.

That is a narrow statement, and it is the most careful one in the file. An altercation on the flight deck is not a proven plan to kill everyone on board. A landing by spare crew is not a miracle written for a campaign. The airline did not name a faith, a state, or a plot.

Other facts sit beside that statement and do not depend on Jerusalem. CNN’s timeline put departure at 6:05 a.m. Dubai time, a distress call at 8:31 a.m., a 7500 squawk minutes later, and touchdown at Tabuk at 9:54 a.m. Public tracking showed a sharp loss of height and a turn to the north. Passengers described screams and blood. Video from the cabin, which CNN said it had checked, shows a wounded pilot being helped and another man being watched. The Emirates attorney general, Hamad Saif al-Shamsi, ordered an inquiry on 1 October. Saudi officers held the suspect.

What leaders said before the motive was known

Netanyahu moved faster than the airline. He said one pilot stabbed the other and tried to crash the plane with everyone on it. He named the wounded captain, praised him for opening the cockpit door while bleeding, and said Israeli passengers had stopped “a 9/11 disaster.” Defense Minister Israel Katz called it an attempted jihadist attack. On Fox News the next day, Netanyahu said the suspect, whom Israel identifies as an Omani national, had gone through “Islamist radical indoctrination,” and that early signs pointed to a man who meant to die with the jet. He did not publish the file he said this came from. The man’s name is still not public.

Then came the line that traveled farther than the flight track. News18 and several outlets carried Netanyahu on the “miracle”:

“This is Hollywood on steroids. You can’t make this up. You can’t believe that it actually happens in real life, but it did.”

He also said a passenger, asked how he knew what to do at the controls, answered that he had watched air-crash films. That passenger, Yaniv Hayoun, later told the same story himself: he had seen Air Crash Investigation, put the attacker in a chokehold, and held the controls until a pilot took over. Supporters call that nerve. Skeptics call it a plot point. It is an odd detail for a prime minister to volunteer if the aim is to sound like a police briefing.

President Donald Trump, speaking in the Oval Office the same day, gave reporters a long account and then added a caveat most headlines dropped. Reuters quoted him: “This is the story that I heard — I don’t know if it’s true, but that’s the story that I got from Bibi.” A head of state repeating another head of state’s tale, and flagging that he cannot vouch for it, is a crack in the chorus.

The New York Times noted a larger crack. Israeli officials and passengers said one pilot attacked the other and seemed to be trying to bring the jet down. The authorities in the Emirates, where the flight began, and in Saudi Arabia, where it landed, had not confirmed that account. Confirmation may come. It had not come when the hero reel was already cut.

The numbers CNN’s own pilot would not bless

This is the part the first-day story did not budget for. On Erin Burnett OutFront, commercial pilot and instructor Aaron Murphy sat in a simulator and tried to fly the drop that public tracking had advertised. The segment’s own framing was stark: a plunge of nearly 20,000 feet in about 35 seconds, with speeds near 700 miles an hour. Murphy’s reply, preserved on the CNN transcript and in the simulator clip, was not a shrug.

“Some of the numbers that we’re seeing from the reporting initially don’t make sense to me because if you’re descending that rapidly, the aircraft would have disintegrated completely. So the numbers will change when we get the preliminary report.”

Burnett did not wave him off. She noted that those were the only numbers then in public, and that rudder damage was already visible, with sections apparently torn away in flight. Murphy said that sight gave him a chill, because ripping that structure can bleed hydraulic fluid and take other systems with it. A plane with a shredded rudder did not simply walk away. It was lucky, well handled, or both.

The published figures do not even agree with each other. CNN’s written recap said 17,400 feet in just under two minutes. Reuters said nearly 14,000 feet in less than 30 seconds. The OutFront introduction said nearly 20,000 feet in 35 seconds. Those are not rounding errors. A two-minute descent and a 35-second descent are different events. Early flight-tracking plots, built from radio reports the plane sends about its own height and speed, are known to spit out wild spikes when a jet is turning hard, diving, or losing a clean signal. Murphy said the early plot would have broken the jet, so the early plot is probably wrong. He did not say nothing happened. He said the tape will correct the poster.

That is the clean reading. There is a rougher one, and it spread within hours. If the number used to sell a near-crash cannot survive a simulator, what else in the telling was fitted to the picture? Clips of Murphy moved fast on X. Posts calling the episode a false flag followed. People who already thought official terror stories are written in advance were waiting for a seam. Murphy handed them one, live, on the network that had also carried Netanyahu’s “9/11” line.

Two readings, and what each leaves out

The case that this was a real attack

The case for a real cockpit attack does not rest on Netanyahu’s adjectives. It rests on things that are hard to stage in Saudi airspace with a foreign airline, a foreign captain, and cameras in the cabin.

Passengers, speaking separately, described the same core: a sudden drop, screaming, a fight at the front, a man with a blade, a captain covered in cuts. Dr. Shota Musaev told reporters the wounded pilot’s head and hands were sliced open. Reuters said a 51-year-old passenger was treated in Israel for a mild upper-body injury. The Jerusalem Post published a photo of rudder damage. Flydubai confirmed an altercation and a landing by spare crew who were already on board — airlines often deadhead crew, so the detail is less convenient than it sounds. The 7500 code is not typed by a press office. Someone in that cockpit set it. The Emirates and Saudi Arabia took the pilots. India’s prime minister praised Machchhar by name. A staged film does not usually end with the star in a foreign hospital and the set parked in a country that does not take Israeli orders.

Weapon questions cut both ways, but they do not erase the blood. Netanyahu has said knife, and also axe. Cockpits carry a crash axe. If that was the weapon, the attacker did not need to smuggle a prop through Dubai security. He needed the access he already had.

The case that the telling was built too fast

Israel votes on 27 October 2026. The day before this flight, Netanyahu had already warned of attacks ahead of that vote. Opposition leader Yair Lapid accused him of spreading fear. Within hours of the drop, Katz had the word “jihadist” on the record, and Netanyahu had Iran in the next sentence — “we’ll find out very soon” whether Tehran was behind it — while also saying he could not say so yet. A link left hanging can be confirmed later, or it can sit in the air until the polls close. Netanyahu told CNN that UAE President Mohammed bin Zayed had agreed Israel would join the questioning. That is access. It is not a finding.

Oman and Israel have no formal ties. Netanyahu himself said an Omani pilot should not have been on an Israel-bound jet under Israeli rules. He has not answered who cleared this crew, and when. A security state that screens pilots, then stars in the rescue story, will be asked that by people who are not fans.

The shape of the tale also matches a screenplay more neatly than most real emergencies. A radical co-pilot. A bleeding captain who uses his last strength to pop the door. Passengers storm the cockpit. One of them learned the controls from television. A spare crew lands in the desert. The prime minister calls it a film, then insists you must believe it. Planet Today’s earlier file, Flydubai Cockpit Stabbing: What Leaders Said and What Stays Unsaid, made the same split on day one: the drop is on the track, the motive is not, and campaign talk arrived before police talk.

None of that proves a false flag. In the strict sense, that phrase means a state staged the violence and blamed someone else. The public record does not show that. It shows a violent cockpit event, a wounded captain, a torn rudder, a political class that named the villain before the airline named a motive, and height figures a CNN pilot said would have turned the jet to scrap. Holding those together is harder than picking a team. It is also closer to what the tape will have to explain.

The election, the war, and the unused Iran line

The flight did not happen in a quiet month. Israel votes on 27 October 2026. The campaign is already a fight about 7 October 2023, about who was warned, and about whether fear is a governing tool. That fight is also in court: Yair Golan’s suit against Sara Netanyahu is the same campaign, in a different room. A foiled attack on a planeload of Israelis, four weeks out, lands in that room whether or not anyone planned it that way.

The wider war is the other room. American and Israeli strikes on Iran began on 28 February 2026. Planet Today’s note on Trump’s ceasefire refusal is the backdrop Netanyahu stepped into when he said investigators would soon know if Iran had a hand in the cockpit. He has not produced that hand. Leaving the door open is a political option, not evidence. Katz’s June line on space lasers sits in the same habit of a large claim and a thin public exhibit: Israel Space Lasers: Katz’s Quote Versus the Orbital Ring Claim.

Saudi Arabia’s role fits neither cartoon. Riyadh took the jet, held the suspect, and, according to the Jerusalem Post, would not let an Israeli Air Force or El Al plane collect the passengers early, for fear Netanyahu would use the scene as an election and normalization prop. If that reporting holds, the Saudis saw the political use of the landing before most viewers did. A state staging a false flag does not usually park the evidence in a capital that is keeping its distance. A state milking a real scare does exactly what the Post described the Saudis as trying to block.

What the boxes can still change

The next facts are physical, not rhetorical. Cockpit voice and flight-data recorders will show who touched the controls, what the jet actually did, and whether anyone tried to push the nose down after the door opened. The UAE inquiry, which Israel says it will join, will have to name the suspect and test the “indoctrination” claim against a document, not a television hit. Oman has not rushed to own or deny the man. That silence is not proof of guilt or of a frame.

Until those papers move, the honest list is short.

Settled: on 30 September 2026 a flydubai jet from Dubai to Tel Aviv had a violent fight on the flight deck, dropped, squawked hijack, and landed at Tabuk with a damaged rudder, flown there by spare crew. The captain was badly hurt. Passengers restrained a second pilot. The airline says the motive is unknown.

Claimed, not yet shown in public documents: a planned crash, a jihadist motive, Iranian direction, and a drop rate that a CNN pilot said the airframe could not have survived.

Useful either way to a campaign: Israeli passengers saving a planeload of Israelis, told by a prime minister who compared it to a film and asked the country to believe the film was real.

The reader does not have to pick a team to see the seam. Mainstream outlets ran the hero cut because passengers, video, and a torn tail were enough for a day-one story. Alternative feeds ran the false-flag cut because the prime minister said “Hollywood,” the height numbers failed a simulator, and an election is close. Both cuts skip work. One skips the blood and the landing in a country Israel does not control. The other skips the speed with which a motive was named, the unused Iran line, and a drop rate that the network’s own expert would not sign. The black boxes will talk. They will not talk in a slogan.

Sources

Original brief this piece answers: a 2 October 2026 social-media write-up built on the CNN Murphy segment and on posts such as this X clip. That write-up treats the false-flag reading as the finding. The record above does not.

Note on sources

This article separates what flydubai, CNN, Reuters, and the New York Times have on the record from claims made by Israeli leaders and from claims made in alternative feeds. Flight-track figures from 30 September are early public data and are already disputed by a pilot on CNN. No black-box transcript has been released. A false-flag claim is a theory, not a finding. Readers should wait for the UAE-led inquiry and the flight-data report before treating any one telling as closed. Fact-checkers can test every quoted line against the links above.

Rašyti komentarą

Ką manote jūs? Parašykite savo nuomonę – kiekvienas komentaras svarbus! 😊 Būkite mandagūs. Draudžiama spaminti ar reklamuoti.

Naujesnė Senesni

Nemokami skelbimai

Susisiekimo forma