Elonas Muskas „NYT DealBook“ laidoje: jis atmeta „Rusijos apologeto“ etiketę ir teigia, kad Zelenskis meluoja dėl „Starlink“

2026 m. lapkričio 18 d. vykusioje „New York Times DealBook“ viršūnių susitikime Elonas Muskas susidūrė su tiesioginiais klausimais dėl teiginių, kad jis yra Rusijos gynėjas. Jis atsakė, nurodydamas savo ankstesnę poziciją Ukrainos klausimu ir sakydamas, kad...

Antraštės ir trumpo aprašymo vertimas atliktas automatiškai. Sudomino? Įsijunkite vertimą.


At the New York Times DealBook Summit on 18 November 2026, Elon Musk faced direct questions about claims that he is a Russian apologist. He answered by pointing to his own record on Ukraine and by saying Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky is not always truthful about Starlink. The exchange raises a clear question: if the same man who kept Ukrainian communications running after the 2022 invasion is still accused of helping the other side, what exactly did he say, and which parts of the record support or challenge that view?

Elon Musk at NYT DealBook: He Rejects Russian Apologist Label and Calls Zelensky Untruthful on Starlink

What the Forensic Expert Claims

What Musk Said About the Russian Apologist Charge

Andrew Ross Sorkin pressed Musk on the idea that he sides with Moscow. Musk answered without waiting for the full question. He stated that Russia is the aggressor in the current war. At the same time he said the United States staged a coup in 2014 to remove the democratically elected president who leaned toward Russia. He described that step as an offensive action that would not have happened without help from the State Department and other agencies.

Musk then listed actions that, in his view, do not match the picture of a Russian ally. SpaceX has cut Russian space activity by roughly two-thirds. The company has no business in Russia. Before the full-scale invasion he made sure Starlink terminals were already in Ukraine. When Russian forces disabled cell towers, fiber lines, and other satellite systems, Starlink was the one network they could not shut down. Musk said that without it the Ukrainian front would have collapsed and Russia would have won. He asked the audience whether that record sounds like a pro-Russian action. He added that no private person has helped Ukraine more than he has, and that turning Starlink off today would make the Ukrainian line collapse at once.

“Russia is the aggressor, but it’s also true that we as America staged a coup to overthrow the democratically-elected pro-Russian President of Ukraine.”

“If they had not had Starlink, their entire line would have collapsed because they had no communication system and Russia would have won. Now, does that sound like a pro-Russian action to you?”

These statements match the clips shared by Eric Daugherty and others on X. They also appear in the summary posted by ZeroHedge under the headline that matches the video circulating from the summit. The same points are reported by The Verge and several wire services that covered the session.

The Starlink and Starshield Distinction

The second sharp exchange concerned Ukraine’s satellite service. Zelensky has complained that restrictions on Starshield, the military version, slow connections when devices move faster than about 161 kilometers per hour. Musk said that claim is false. He told Sorkin that Zelensky is not always truthful and that the Ukrainian leader is in fact asking to use the commercial Starlink system for offensive military operations.

Musk repeated a line he has used before: Starlink is a civilian network. It is not meant for offensive drone strikes that kill people. Those decisions belong to Starshield, the separate system controlled by the US government. In that system the choice to authorize a strike rests with the War Department or the president, not with a private company owner. SpaceX has declined to open commercial Starlink for offensive use from the start of the conflict. Musk said the current speed limit matches the maximum highway speed in Ukraine and that the company has not turned the service off.

“That’s false. I don’t want to blow your mind, but Zelensky is not always truthful.”

“He is lying. What he is actually saying is he wants to use Starlink for offensive military operations.”

“Do not ask me as a private individual to make kill decisions.”

The Verge, the Straits Times, and AFP all carried the same core quotes. Benny Johnson posted a clip of the exchange on X within hours. The distinction between the two systems has been public for years. Starshield is the version sold to the US military and other governments. Starlink is the consumer and commercial service. Musk has said repeatedly that he will not let the commercial constellation become a party to the war by enabling strikes deep inside Russia.

Background on the Speed Limits and Earlier Disputes

The argument is not new. In October 2026 Ukrainian forces reported that terminals still lost connection above roughly 160 km/h even after President Trump said Musk had restored access. Tests described by Ukrainian advisers showed limits of 140–160 km/h and navigation problems that made it hard to intercept faster Russian drones. Responsibility for the slowdown was disputed. Some reports said Musk ordered it after talks with administration officials. Others pointed to the White House. Trump said he had called Musk to reverse it. Musk has said the military systems are controlled by the US government, so usage rules are set by the Pentagon and ultimately the president.

Earlier in October Musk replied to a White House video with the short comment that Zelensky had gone too far after Ukrainian strikes on Russian diesel refineries. Those strikes raised fuel prices that affected American farmers. Planet Today covered that episode and the later speed-limit reports. The same outlet also noted Ukrainian interest in other satellite systems, including a letter of intent with Finnish firms, as a way to reduce dependence on one provider.

Musk’s position has stayed consistent on one point: he will not authorize commercial Starlink for offensive operations that he believes would escalate the war. He has also said it is time for Ukraine to make a deal. Zelensky has asked Trump and others to press Musk for wider coverage. Those requests have not been granted.

How the 2014 Claim Is Viewed

Musk’s statement that the United States staged a coup in 2014 drew immediate push-back. Several people who live in or know Ukraine replied on X that the events of late 2013 and early 2014 were driven by street protests after then-President Viktor Yanukovych shelved an EU agreement. Police killed demonstrators. Yanukovych later fled. The Ukrainian parliament voted to hold early elections. Critics called the “US coup” description Russian propaganda. Supporters of Musk’s view point to long-standing US funding for Ukrainian civil-society groups and to the presence of senior American officials in Kyiv during the unrest. Both readings have been public for more than a decade. The summit clip simply put Musk’s version on the record again.

Independent reporting from 2014 shows that the United States and European governments openly backed the protesters and the new government that followed. Whether that support crossed the line into a staged coup remains a matter of judgment. Musk presented it as a fact. Others treat it as a contested claim.

What People Are Saying

On X the clips spread quickly. Eric Daugherty’s post of the Russian-apologist segment drew thousands of likes and hundreds of replies. Benny Johnson’s clip of the Zelensky exchange did the same. Some users wrote that Eastern Europeans already know Zelensky is not always honest. Others said Musk has been caught in false statements before and that his version should not be taken at face value. A few Ukrainian voices called the 2014 remark embarrassing and imperialist. Russian Embassy accounts in Europe posted their own commentary on related events, including Dutch involvement in earlier strikes, but those posts did not address the DealBook interview directly.

The split in replies mirrors the larger split in coverage. Outlets that treat Musk as a reliable narrator highlight his Starlink record and his refusal to make private kill decisions. Outlets that treat him as unreliable focus on his past contacts with Russian officials and on his public calls for a negotiated end to the war. Both sets of facts are available to readers.

Why the Distinction Matters

Starlink terminals in Ukraine number in the tens of thousands. They carry military communications, drone control links, and civilian internet. A private company owns the constellation. The US government owns and controls the military-grade version. When a private owner draws a line between civilian use and offensive strikes, the practical result is that some Ukrainian operations are limited by speed or by geography. Ukrainian commanders say those limits hurt their ability to intercept drones and to strike Russian targets. Musk says the alternative is to turn a commercial service into a weapon system whose existence could then be threatened by the other side.

The same tension appears in other private systems used in war. When a company can switch a network on or off, or slow it down, governments notice. Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney, speaking at the same summit, said dependence on Starlink had turned from an advantage into a vulnerability in Ukraine. He asked who would decide whether the system stays on when the stakes rise. That question is now part of the public record.

Musk’s answer at DealBook was that he will not make the kill decision himself and that he will not open the commercial network for offensive use. He also said Russia started the current phase of the war and that Starlink has been the reason the Ukrainian line has not collapsed. Those two statements sit side by side. Readers can weigh the record of support against the record of limits and decide which description fits.

Related reading on this site includes the earlier report on why Ukraine still faces Starlink speed limits after Trump’s claims and the piece on Musk’s short comment that Zelensky had gone too far. Both add background to the exchange that took place on 18 November.

Original source material includes the DealBook Summit interview of 18 November 2026, clips posted by Eric Daugherty, Benny Johnson, and ZeroHedge, and same-day reporting by The Verge, the Straits Times, and AFP. Full link to the main ZeroHedge item that carried the video summary: ZeroHedge, 19 November 2026. Planet Today coverage of prior Starlink limits: Why Ukraine Still Faces Starlink Speed Limits After Trump Claims.

Disclaimer for fact-checkers: This article reports public statements made by Elon Musk at the New York Times DealBook Summit on 18 November 2026, as captured in widely shared video clips and same-day news reports. It also notes the main counter-arguments that appeared in replies and in prior coverage of the 2014 events in Ukraine. No claim is presented as settled beyond the direct quotations. Readers should consult the primary video and the original news reports for the full context.

Rašyti komentarą

Ką manote jūs? Parašykite savo nuomonę – kiekvienas komentaras svarbus! 😊 Būkite mandagūs. Draudžiama spaminti ar reklamuoti.

Naujesnė Senesni

Nemokami skelbimai

Susisiekimo forma